Upfront Costs vs. Maintenance for Inground Swimming Pools

Jason Craycraft • May 20, 2023
Upfront Costs vs. Maintenance for Inground Swimming Pools

You might have already made the decision to have an inground swimming pool installed on your property. Now, it’s time to decide what type of pool you are going to go with. Two popular options are fiberglass and vinyl inground swimming pools. When you’re trying to decide between the two, you will probably want to consider things like cost and maintenance. Then, you can decide which type of inground swimming pool might be right for you and your family.

What is the Most Affordable Swimming Pool Type to Install?

Fire Pit and Swimming Pool

You might already know that installing any type of swimming pool on your property will require an investment. This is even more true with inground swimming pools, which are more expensive than most above-ground options. However, if you’re hoping to stick to a fairly reasonable budget when installing an inground swimming pool, you could be curious about which option is going to be the most affordable.

Generally, pools with vinyl liners are more affordable than fiberglass swimming pools. However, even though the upfront costs might be cheaper with these swimming pools, you’ll probably spend more over the lifetime of your pool if you choose a vinyl pool. This is because these vinyl liners do have to be replaced every few years.

Also, be aware that even though fiberglass pools are usually more expensive than pools with vinyl liners, the cost difference might not be as significant as you think. Both pool options are typically more affordable than standard concrete pools.

How Else Can You Reduce Swimming Pool Installation Costs?

Swimming Pool with Water Fountain

Since the upfront installation cost of installing a fiberglass pool does cost more in most cases, you could be wondering if there is anything that you can do to keep this cost down. In addition to the construction of the pool, there are other things that impact the pricing as well, such as the design and the size.

You will obviously want to make sure that the pool is large enough that you and your family members can all enjoy it. You may even want to make sure that there is extra space for when you invite guests over. However, your pool might not have to be as large as you think. Since you will not have to share it with the public, even a smaller pool might be just fine. In fact, it might be ideal to go with a smaller size; not only will it be cheaper and easier to install and maintain, but it will not take up as much space in your yard, either.

If cutting down on costs is important to you, then you might want to opt for a simple design, too. Freeform pools or pools with custom shapes are typically on the more expensive side, for example. Opting for a simple, classic style can help you keep your costs down, regardless of if you choose fiberglass, vinyl or even concrete.

Which Pools are Easier and Cheaper to Maintain?

Swimming Pool and Stamped Concrete Deck

You probably want your pool to be a fun addition to your household, not something that you’re going to regret or that is going to put you in a financial bind. You don’t just have to worry about the cost of your swimming pool when you first install it; you also have to think about how much it will cost for you to maintain your pool over the years. Many families find that having a swimming pool fits comfortably into their budgets, but you will want to be aware of and prepared for the expenses so that you can take care of and truly enjoy your swimming pool.

Lifetime expenses are typically higher for pools with vinyl liners. No matter how careful you are with your pool liner, it will have to be replaced in a few years. Over time, the cost of replacing pool liners can really add up. Fiberglass pools typically last for years with little maintenance needed. In fact, many manufacturers of fiberglass pool shells even offer lifetime warranties on their products.

How Can You Reduce Pool Maintenance Costs?

Pool Maintenance

If you choose a pool with a vinyl liner, you could be concerned about just how much money you will have to shell out to pay for swimming pool maintenance over the years. Being careful about things like keeping pets out of the pool is important. After all, pet claws can easily scratch your pool liner, causing it to have to be replaced a lot more quickly.

Even if you choose a fiberglass pool that has lower maintenance costs over time, you’ll still have costs for pool maintenance. If you would like to reduce these costs, there are ways that you can do so.

For example, you might choose to use a pool service like Omni Pools to help you with keeping your fiberglass or vinyl pool clean. Learning how to do some of the work yourself can help you save on these costs. It might take a little bit of time and research to determine how to use pool chemicals properly and how to clean your pool efficiently and effectively, you may find that it is worth it so that you can enjoy reduced costs.

You can often purchase accessories for taking care of your pool for less, too. Buying chemicals for your pool in bulk might be a great idea, for example; you may be able to find them on sale at the end of the summer, for example, and stocking up will help you score the lowest price on chemicals for next year and will help you avoid running out.

Since installing a swimming pool is a big decision, it’s important to choose the right type of swimming pool. The tips above will help you with making your decision, but you’ll probably also want to consult a professional. If you live in central Ohio, contact us at Omni Pools & Scapes today so that we can talk to you about your different pool installation options.

RECENT POSTS

Aerial view of a luxurious backyard with a pool, patio, and manicured landscaping; a large house is in the background.
By JASON CRAYCRAFT July 24, 2025
At Omni Pools & Scapes, we love building dream backyards. But before we break ground (literally), there are a few things we wish every client knew. Think of this as your poolside pre-game checklist—minus the sunscreen (but seriously, wear sunscreen).
By JASON CRAYCRAFT December 4, 2024
As the leaves fall and temperatures drop, December marks the time to think about closing your pool for the winter season. Here at Omni Pools & Scapes, we understand that proper winterization is crucial for protecting your pool and ensuring it's ready for use come spring. Here's your step-by-step guide to shutting down your pool the right way: Why Winterize Your Pool? Winterizing your pool isn't just a tradition; it's essential for: Preventing Damage : Ice can expand and crack your pool's structure or equipment. Avoiding Algae and Bacteria : Cold weather doesn't kill all microorganisms, so proper chemical treatment is necessary. Maintaining Water Quality : Ensuring your pool water remains balanced during winter minimizes the effort needed to reopen it. Step-by-Step Winterization Process: Balance the Water Chemistry: Test for pH, alkalinity, calcium hardness, and chlorine levels. Adjust as necessary to keep your water in balance, which helps in preventing algae and scale during the off-season. Clean the Pool Thoroughly: Remove leaves, debris, and vacuum the pool to leave it clean. Brush the walls to dislodge any dirt or algae. Clean or backwash your filter to ensure it's not clogged with debris from the season. Lower the Water Level: For pools in colder climates like Ohio, lower the water level below the skimmer and return lines to prevent ice damage. However, for pools with an auto-cover, maintain a level that doesn't interfere with the cover's ability to seal. Drain and Store Equipment: Drain the pump, filter, heater, and any other equipment to protect from freezing temperatures. Follow manufacturer guidelines for storage. Remove and store ladders, diving boards, and other accessories in a dry place to prevent rust or damage. Add Winterizing Chemicals: Use a winterizing kit or add chemicals separately to prevent algae growth and maintain water clarity. This typically includes: Shock treatment to kill off any remaining algae and bacteria. Algaecide to prevent growth during winter. Sequestering agents to prevent staining from metals in the water. Install the Pool Cover: For above-ground pools, a solid cover is essential. For in-ground pools, mesh or solid covers can be used, depending on your preference for water management during winter. Ensure the cover is secure and tight to keep out debris and to minimize water accumulation on top. Circulate Water One Last Time: Run your pump with the winterizing chemicals to distribute them evenly. Then, shut down your system. Protect Against Freeze: Use pool antifreeze in skimmer and return lines to prevent freezing and damage. Consider a pool heater or invest in a freeze protection system if you live in an area with extreme cold snaps. 
By JASON CRAYCRAFT November 17, 2024
At Omni Pools & Scapes, we believe that the beauty of a well-designed pool area extends beyond the water itself. Hardscaping plays a pivotal role in defining the functionality and aesthetic appeal of your outdoor living space. Let's explore how to integrate hardscapes to elevate your backyard into a true outdoor masterpiece. What is Hardscaping? Hardscaping refers to the non-living features of your landscape, like pathways, patios , retaining walls , and outdoor kitchens . These elements provide structure, facilitate movement, and create focal points or areas for leisure and entertainment. The Role of Hardscaping in Pool Design Functional Aesthetics : Patios : A well-designed patio around your pool can serve as a deck for sunbathing , a dance floor for parties, or a dining area for al fresco meals. Choose materials that complement your pool's style, whether it's natural stone for a rustic feel or sleek concrete for modern elegance. Walkways : These guide guests around your pool safely while adding to the overall design. They can be made of pavers, gravel, or even wood, depending on the ambiance you wish to create. Defining Spaces : Outdoor Kitchens : Imagine walking from your pool to a fully functional kitchen area. Hardscaping here includes countertops, grills, and seating, turning your backyard into an entertainment zone. Fire Features : From fire pits to outdoor fireplaces , these elements not only extend your pool season into cooler months but also serve as a gathering spot for nighttime enjoyment. Water Management : Retaining Walls : Useful for managing water flow, preventing erosion, and creating multi-level landscapes that add depth and interest. Drainage Systems : Properly designed hardscapes can incorporate elegant solutions for water drainage, ensuring your pool area remains pristine and functional.